Comments on Perpetual Emptiness: Mumbai Dossier... Fact or Fiction?

The whole problem appears to be that all investiga...

2009-01-25T16:10:00.000+05:30

The whole problem appears to be that all investigating agencies add spice to their evidence in order to make it look authentic & complete. There is also the problem to add uncommitted alleged crimes to the list of crimes actually committed so that the accused would get convicted in the "peripheral" ones, if not the main ones. Indeed, this is the bane of all police agencies all over the world, and what happened in a specific case can only be a conjecture

:) Good choice.

2009-01-20T00:56:00.000+05:30

:) Good choice.

I rest my case

2009-01-19T13:06:00.000+05:30

I rest my case

"Does it anywhere say "Added by Indian Police". Ca...

2009-01-16T19:32:00.000+05:30

"Does it anywhere say "Added by Indian Police". Can you find it for me."

if it said that then -

"how do u know its added by indian police, just because it says so? Can you show me video of indian police adding it?"

when video is shown then -

"the police is seen wearing a 'Hindu extremist band, how do u know he's not a fake police and actually indian terrorist?"

:) this is where u r going my dear, just clutching at straws like someone who's entire dreamword has crumbled around him. just not wanting to face reality.

"'hindi translation below' might look interesting....

2009-01-16T14:56:00.000+05:30

"'hindi translation below' might look interesting."

My dear "intelligent" Sachin

Yes I can see that written there, but I am unsure of its purpose.

Does it anywhere say "Added by Indian Police". Can you find it for me.

"indians KNOW pakistanis do not read hindi, so unless u want to take this argument to an irrational level, u r not seriously suggesting indians 'planted' a piece of doc in hindi now, do u? as i said, stop clutching at straws."

Indian terrorists are "irrational arguments", interesting.

However, there was no reason for the Hindi Script.

I am presenting a simple fact that could be raised against the authenticity of the dossier.

My brilliant analyst friend,pls look at what u've ...

2009-01-15T21:22:00.000+05:30

My brilliant analyst friend,

pls look at what u've uploaded first. top, righ hand.

'hindi translation below' might look interesting.

Waiting in the high sees where indian fishermen go...

2009-01-15T21:18:00.000+05:30

Waiting in the high sees where indian fishermen go fishing? not that tough, stop clutching at straws.

Dear Ahmed, why do u assume they scribbled on the original??? its got to be a copy - its not tampering with evidence, but u r interested in diversions, which explifies the pak attitude.

indians KNOW pakistanis do not read hindi, so unless u want to take this argument to an irrational level, u r not seriously suggesting indians 'planted' a piece of doc in hindi now, do u? as i said, stop clutching at straws.

why will india hand over 'original papers' to pak???

Waiting WHERE?!?!?!

2009-01-12T22:06:00.000+05:30

Waiting WHERE?!?!?!

My dear SachinWhat part of "Isn't this tampering w...

2009-01-12T22:05:00.000+05:30

My dear Sachin

What part of "Isn't this tampering with evidence?" you don't understand.

Is it an assumption you make that Indian police added it? or does it say in the document?

How can I tell if it was added before or after if i am not provided the original evidence.

Plus, Pakistani people do not understand HINDI script

First of all, some knowledge on how police record ...

2009-01-11T21:13:00.000+05:30

First of all, some knowledge on how police record evidence would have helped u a bit. police while investigating record ALL circumstantial details, that forms part of 'body of evidence'. hence the pakistani atta and other things mentioned.

secondly, hijacking an indian trawler means that u have to wait for one to show up - thats the ONLY way it can be done. mind u thery were waiting for ANY trawler, not a specific trawler.

Thirdly, the hindi script is a translation done by police for their own understanding. why otherwise would there be a repition??? can we stop feigning 'stupidity' pls?